Module 7
Improving Instructional Design

Reflecting on The Seven-Step Process: A Quilt in the Making

God is a Quilter

I think God is a quilter
Who takes His needle and thread
To piece our world from nothingness
And give it form, instead.

I think God is a quilter;
Stitching tight and tiny rows,
Adding to my scraps and pieces,
Seaming everything He knows.

I think quilts are lessons
God uses just to teach
That our pieces and our remnants
Have kaleidoscopic reach.

So in the life I'm living
With pieces everywhere
I'll give them to the Quilter
To stitch with loving care.

-Anonymous

God,
Where I've treated a piece as the whole,
Forgive me.
Where I need to learn where the pieces fit,
Teach me.
Where I need to finish what I started,
Encourage me.

(Salter, 2001)

Dear God, Protect me from responding to the pieces of my life as the whole story. It is the same as treating pieces of the truth as the whole truth. Help me understand that nothing need be wasted when stitched together by Your will. I offer You my gathered pieces to be stitched together for Your purpose. (Salter, 2001)

Gini Shimabukuro (2000) who has been the inspiration behind Phase II of Catholic Curriculum Online and whose Seven-Step Process of Curriculum Development for Catholic Schools provided the impetus for the development of these modules offers us a quilt work for Improving Instructional Design in Catholic schools. Module 7, which is about assessing the entire Curriculum Development Process, should in no way be viewed as being separate and apart from that which has preceded, nor should it be viewed as something that can only come at the end of the process. Instead, this module should be seen as the thread that is stitched throughout the entire fabric of Catholic Curriculum Development. This Module, along with the previous six modules and introduction, should be viewed as part of the same quilt. All modules were developed with the intention of providing Catholic educators with reflective opportunities geared to the improvement of teaching and learning.

Shimabukuro (2000) writes:

"Ideally, the teacher, at points throughout the cycle, ponders effective as well as ineffective aspects of the curriculum and its delivery, and initiates needed adjustments along the way…. During this reflective undertaking, the teacher might consider such issues as whether continuity was exhibited between each step of the cycle; which curricular areas could have been developed further, eliminated, or rearranged to better promote student understanding; to what extent the religious dimension was meaningfully integrated throughout the process; and the degree to which students were engaged in learning. With the insight derived from dedicated reflection on factors that either hindered or advanced student learning, the teacher then proceeds to implement necessary changes for instructional improvement, and, thus, concludes a complete cycle of learning and instruction among his or her students."

The main goal that we want to achieve in Catholic Curriculum Development is the Education of the Whole Child as has so frequently and eloquently been pointed out in the Catholic school literature. This has become the key pedagogical challenge of Catholic schools. Shimabukuro's Seven-Step Process is an important tool in achieving this most noble of goals.

  • What does the star seen in all the above quilts have in common with the official logo of Catholic Curriculum Online? How can the metaphor of the quilt help us better understand Module 7 which is all about Improving Instructional Design?
  • What can the above poem and quotes teach us about the Curriculum Development in the context of Catholic education?
  • If Catholic Curriculum Development is like a quilt, what are the pieces that we need to put together to form a whole? How do we put the pieces together?
  • In Catholic education, the secular pieces of the quilt need to connect with the Catholic pieces? How is this possible? Is it possible to separate them and still achieve the goals of Catholic education?
  • Where do I, as teacher, fit into the quilt?
  • Use the quilt metaphor to explain what it means to educate the whole child.
  • How can the quilt metaphor help us assess what is good and what is lacking in Catholic Curriculum Development?

The Quilt of Catholic Curriculum Development: What is the Common Thread?

I place before you the colorful spools of God's precious thread. Imagine him sewing the collage of people and events that have shaped the teacher that you have become. They will all be stitched and fitted together with this very unique and precious thread - sewn and fitted into a collage of reminders and assurances of God's presence - a collage of God's people, God's goodness, God's forgiveness, God's care, God's comfort, a collage sustained by God's Word and Holy Sacraments. (Adapted from Kraus, 1998)

It is the cumulative design of the pieces that give the quilt its character, but, it is the thread that holds the quilt together. Catholic Curriculum Development is much the same. To improve instructional design, we need to pay attention to not only the pieces, but also to the thread that holds it all together. The pieces described in Modules 1 through 6 can only take on a shape or design if they are securely bound together by a common thread. When paying attention to Improving Instructional Design, we must constantly be asking ourselves: What is the common thread?

The diagram, Catholic Curriculum Development for Saskatchewan Catholic Schools can perhaps be viewed as a blueprint for the quilt of Catholic Curriculum Development. At the center of the diagram is Jesus himself. To apply our quilt metaphor, Jesus is the thread that binds it all together. In other words, any improvement effort of current curriculum practices in Catholic schools must first assess whether or not this basic thread is in place. It is only by putting Jesus at the center that we can hope to Improve Instructional Design. By so doing, we are free to experiment with, modify and reshape the pieces in a manner that best serves the child and the teaching mission of the Catholic Church.

For Catholic educators to recognize Jesus as the thread of Catholic Curriculum Development and Improvement, they need to know what the thread is made of and they need to have faith in its strength. Once again the diagram, Catholic Curriculum Development for Saskatchewan Catholic Schools can be a valuable tool in understanding where this strength lies. While the formal curriculum is an important contributing factor, the informal curriculum is the final determining factor. However the two are very much interrelated and interconnected.

Borrowed with permission from the Catholic Education Office in Sydney, Australia, the informal curriculum rectangle identifies seven criteria for evaluating Catholic curriculum and Improving Instructional Design. Under each criteria, various reflective questions are proposed. These questions are intended to provoke reflection on the extent to which the Catholic school, in its curriculum, structures, procedures and life, is the kind of place which will promote the desired growth and fullest development of its students. As Catholic Curriculum Designers of Saskatchewan, let's individually and collectively work out our own answers to these questions as we think of each piece of the Catholic educational quilt presented in the previous modules. The following list has been adapted and is not exactly as it appears in the Australian document Purpose and Outcomes (1987).

Whenever you see a thinking character, it's time to STOP, THINK, and REFLECT, and have a PROFESSIONAL CONVERSATION about Improving Instructional Design.

  • What does my school do to promote each of the above criteria?
  • What do I do in my teaching and interactions with others to promote each of the above criteria?
  • How can these criteria help me better understand and incorporate the main principles outlined in each of the seven modules?
  • How can I ensure that these principles are incorporated into my instructional planning and delivery?
  • What other criteria can I add to this section?

Religious: What would be the characteristics of a Catholic school in which students' growth in faith is promoted?

Loving: What are the characteristics of a Catholic school in which students become understanding of themselves and grow in care, concern and compassion for others?

Open to Growth: What features would be apparent in a Catholic school which encourages openness to growth among members of the school community?

Committed to Justice: What are the characteristics of a Catholic school which forms students who are committed to justice?

Intellectually Competent: What are the characteristics of a Catholic school in which students can assimilate knowledge and develop positive attitudes and intellectual skills appropriate to their age and abilities?

Competent in Life Skills: What would be the characteristics of a Catholic school which prepares students to lead a balanced, active and independent life?

Physically Adept: What are the features of a Catholic school which promote and nurture the physical development of its students?

The Cross on the Quilt

We must always make sure that there is room for the cross on our Quilt of Catholic Curriculum Design. The cross is the basic symbol of our Catholic faith. The cross points us in the right direction for all that we do in Catholic education.

As stated in the Australian curriculum evaluation document, Purposes and Outcomes (1987), the criteria presented thus far is designed to assist schools and individual teachers "evaluate whether or not their curriculum, organization and philosophy lend themselves to the development of graduates who are RELIGIOUS, LOVING, OPEN TO GROWTH, COMMITTED TO JUSTICE, INTELLECTUALLY COMPETENT, COMPETENT IN LIFE SKILLS, and PHYSICALLY ADEPT. While it can be argued that many of these hoped-for qualities reflect the special identity of the truly CATHOLIC school, this final section addresses particularly the question: What is distinctive about the CATHOLIC school in contrast to other schools which also profess a religious/Christian vision?"

Catholic: What are the visible signs that a school is genuinely Catholic?

The Sacred Congregation Speaks

While it is true that parents are the first and foremost educators of their own children and that the rights and duties that they have in this regard are "original and primary with respect to the educational role of others", it is also true that among the means which will assist and complement the exercise of the educational rights and duties of the family, the school has a value and an importance that are fundamental. In virtue of its mission, then the school must be concerned with constant and careful attention to cultivating the intellectual, creative, and aesthetic faculties of the human person; to develop in them the ability to make correct use of their judgment, will, and affectivity; to promote in them a sense of values; to encourage just attitudes and prudent behaviour; to introduce them to the cultural patrimony handed from previous generations; to prepare them for professional life, and to encourage a friendly interchange among students of diverse cultures and backgrounds that will lead to mutual understanding. For all these reasons, the school enters into the specific mission of the Church.

Final Task

Create your own vision for Improving Instructional Design from your perspective as a Catholic educator. Communicate your vision by drawing and decorating a quilt which shows what you believe to be the essential pieces. Write a brief description beside your quilt which articulates that which you tried to visually show in your quilt. If you like, use this blueprint to design and create an actual quilt to hang in your classroom or school entrance.

Resources:

Combs, Arthur W. (1999). On Becoming a School Leader. Alexandria,Virginia: Association for Curriculum and Instruction.

Kraus, Helen (1998). The Golden Thread of God's Presence. (Web article). Cape Elizabeth, Maine.

Purposes and Outcomes for Catholic Schools. (1987). Catholic Education Office. Sydney, Australia.
(Permission granted to post material from this book onto our website)

Shimabukuro, Gini. (2000). "Teaching and Learning in the Catholic School". Catholic School Leadership: An Invitation to Lead. Falmer Press. London and New York.

Salter, Debbie. (2001). Quilted With Love : Discovering the Patterns of Life's Grace and Beauty. Honor Books. Tulsa, Oklahoma

Totten, Betsy. (Born 1781). Quilt: "Rising Sun". Smithsonian: National Museum of American History. The pieced sun pattern at the center of the quilt is an eight-pointed star that measures 76 inches across and contains 648 diamond-shaped pieces of printed cotton.